Today Dr. Dan Korman and Noah McKay join me to discuss evolutionary debunking arguments. Can our moral beliefs survive skeptical threats?
Like the show? Help it grow! Consider becoming a patron (thanks!): / majestyofreason.
If you wanna make a one-time donation or tip (thanks!): https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/josep… 0:00 Intro 1:40 Debunking arguments 6:22 Three kinds of debunking arguments 14:43 Telic debunking argument 22:05 Explanationist pushback 38:51 Swampman pushback 59:51 New function pushback 1:16:45 Dan’s favored approach 1:25:01 Concluding thoughts RESOURCES Dan’s website (with his papers): https://danielzkorman.weebly.com/ Noah’s website (with his papers): https://noahdmckay.wordpress.com/ Dan’s paper, “Debunking Arguments”, https://philarchive.org/archive/KORDA-2 Dan’s paper, “An explanationist Account of Genealogical Defeat ”, https://philpapers.org/rec/KORAEA-4 Noah’s paper, ” Can Rational Reflection Save Moral Knowledge from Debunking?”, https://philpapers.org/rec/MCKCRR Noah’s paper, ” Moral knowledge and the existence of God”, https://philpapers.org/rec/MCKMKA My Metaethics playlist: • Metaethics My Springer book: (a) https://www.amazon.com/Existential-In?tag=lifeboatfound-20… (b) https://link.springer.com/book/10.100… THE USUAL… Follow the Majesty of Reason podcast! https://open.spotify.com/show/4Nda5uN… Join the Discord and chat all things philosophy! https://dsc.gg/majestyofreason My website: https://josephschmid.com My PhilPeople profile: https://philpeople.org/profiles/josep…
OUTLINE
A study of artificial human and chimpanzee nerve cells revealed how faster-evolving DNA enables neurons to develop increasingly complex brain power.
How did humans evolve brains capable of complex language, civilization, and more?
The answer may lie in exceptional DNA. Scientists at UC San Francisco discovered that certain regions of our chromosomes have evolved at remarkable speeds, giving us an advantage in brain development over apes. However, this rapid evolution may also make us more susceptible to uniquely human brain disorders.
A new source of nitrogen has been discovered. Researchers from RPTU University Kaiserslautern-Landau in southwestern Germany are unraveling the mysteries of a bygone era. As part of ongoing studies, they are investigating how life could have developed on early Earth. Contrary to previous assumptions, biologically available nitrogen does not appear to have been a limiting factor.
Astronomers have performed a multiwavelength study of nine open cluster candidates. As a result, they found that all of them are genuine open clusters and characterized by their fundamental properties. The finding was reported in a research paper published Feb. 21 on the arXiv pre-print server.
Open clusters (OCs), formed from the same giant molecular cloud, are groups of stars loosely gravitationally bound to each other. So far, more than 1,000 of them have been discovered in the Milky Way, and scientists are still looking for more, hoping to find a variety of these stellar groupings.
Expanding the list of known galactic open clusters and studying them in detail could be crucial for improving our understanding of the formation and evolution of our galaxy.
The results show two distinct patterns in the protective effect of natural infection against reinfection in the Omicron era compared to the pre-Omicron era. Before the emergence of Omicron, natural infection offered robust protection against reinfection, with roughly 80% effectiveness and minimal signs of waning over time after the infection. However, during the Omicron era, this protection was strong only for recently infected individuals, rapidly declining over time after the infection and ultimately diminishing within a year. These patterns were consistent regardless of whether any infection or only symptomatic infection was considered as an outcome, and for both vaccinated and unvaccinated populations.
The two distinct patterns observed in the Omicron versus pre-Omicron eras provide population-level results that validate previous experimental molecular evidence1,2,18,19,20, and are probably the result of a complex interplay of several interrelated factors, in addition to waning immunity, immune evasion and the accelerated and convergent evolution of Omicron, such as immune imprinting, varying immunogenicity, global population immunity faced by the strains and population characteristics associated with infections at different stages of the pandemic.
Whereas these factors are interconnected and challenging to disentangle, the observed differences in protection against reinfection may stem from distinct evolutionary pressures acting on SARS-CoV-2 during the pre-Omicron and Omicron eras. In the pre-Omicron era, with a large proportion of individuals remaining immune naive because of non-pharmaceutical interventions and delayed scale-up of vaccination, intrinsic transmissibility may have been the primary driver of viral adaptation. This was evidenced by the emergence of more transmissible variants such as Alpha4,22,23 and Delta24,25. Conversely, following the very large and widespread Omicron wave in early 2022 (Extended Data Fig. 3)26, most individuals possessed some level of immunity, either from infection or vaccination. This may have shifted the dominant evolutionary pressure towards immune escape through not only antigenic drift, but also recombination and convergent evolution as the adaptive mechanisms for the virus2,18,27,28.
Among the roughly 10 billion white dwarf stars in the Milky Way galaxy, a greater number than previously expected could provide a stellar environment hospitable to life-supporting exoplanets, according to astronomers at the University of California, Irvine.
In a paper published recently in The Astrophysical Journal, a research team led by Aomawa Shields, UC Irvine associate professor of physics and astronomy, share the results of a study comparing the climates of exoplanets at two different stars.
One is a hypothetical white dwarf that’s passed through much of its life cycle and is on a slow path to stellar death. The other subject is Kepler-62, a “main sequence” star at a similar phase in its evolution as our sun.
Humanity came close to extinction 800,000 years ago. Only 1,280 of our ancestors survived.
A recent study published in Science suggests that a catastrophic “ancestral bottleneck” reduced the global population to just 1,280 breeding individuals, wiping out 98.7% of the early human lineage.
This population crash, lasting about 117,000 years, likely resulted from extreme climate shifts, prolonged droughts, and dwindling food sources.
Using a groundbreaking genetic analysis method called FitCoal, researchers analyzed modern human genomes to trace this dramatic decline, potentially explaining a gap in the African and Eurasian fossil record.
Despite the near-extinction, this bottleneck may have played a crucial role in shaping modern humans. Scientists believe it contributed to a key evolutionary event—chromosome fusion—which may have set Homo sapiens apart from earlier hominin species, including Neanderthals and Denisovans. The study raises intriguing questions about how this small population survived, possibly through early fire use and adaptive intelligence. Understanding this ancient crisis helps scientists piece together the story of human evolution and the resilience that allowed our species to thrive against all odds.
The araneopathogenic genus Gibellula (Cordycipitaceae: Hypocreales) in the British Isles, including a new zombie species on orb-weaving cave spiders (Metainae: Tetragnathidae)
Authors: Evans, H.C. 1 ; Fogg, T. 2 ; Buddie, A.G. 1 ; Yeap, Y.T. 1 ; Araújo, J.P.M. 3, 4 ;
Source: Fungal Systematics and Evolution
Publisher: Westerdijk Fungal Biodiversity Institute
This machine could reveal the universe’s deepest secrets.
Ghost particle s mass, its bizarre shape-shifting behavior, and its role in the evolution of the cosmos. Neutrinos, though abundant, are notoriously elusive, passing through matter with barely a trace. JUNO Theory of Everything.
Summary: A new study reveals that human accelerated regions (HARs)—segments of DNA that evolved much faster than expected—may be key to the brain’s advanced cognitive abilities. Researchers compared human and chimpanzee neurons and found that HARs drive the growth of multiple neural projections, which enhance communication between brain cells.
When human HARs were introduced into chimp neurons, they also grew more projections, suggesting a direct link between HARs and neural complexity. However, these same genetic changes may also contribute to neurodevelopmental disorders like autism, highlighting the delicate balance of human brain evolution.